Giggs knew Manchester United needed Mourinho after Van Gaal
Few witnessed it but maybe the best insight into the strain David Moyes endured as Manchester United manager came in Athens two years ago. Moyes met his Waterloo at Olympiakos and his authority was undermined not once but twice as he squirmed in the technical area during United's shambolic 2-0 defeat.
"Send him off," one substitute hollered at the fourth official as Moyes bickered with him. "We would be better off without him." That insubordination was followed by coaches convincing the Scot not to turn to Marouane Fellaini , preparing to emerge, as United scraped for an away goal. Fellaini remained on the bench.
Ryan Giggs has spent the majority of the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era in the United dugout, attempting to block out the jeers and the catcalls that pierced the atmosphere in farcical home defeats to Liverpool, City, Norwich and Southampton over two turbulent years. He was a junior as a coach but could have shown seniority and empathy for his superiors. Like Fellaini, he almost always remained rooted to his seat.
A spirited exception was in the FA Cup final. Referee Mark Clattenburg had just blown for the second-half of extra-time and Giggs morphed from assistant into cheerleader, marching over to United's unusually moribund away support and attempting to whip up an atmosphere, like a Welsh Simeone. It was his last hurrah as a United representative.
By the end, Giggs had apparently become so disillusioned in his coaching role he had no desire to directly succeed Van Gaal because he recognised United required experience to oversee the team's recovery. He was resigned to Mourinho's appointment as early as April.
Ferguson had campaigned passionately for his protege to become United manager and his ambassadorial acolytes also championed Giggs. It was apparent as early as February Giggs' chances of becoming the next United manager had ended and Ferguson settled on Mauricio Pochettino as the alternative.
Giggs might now ponder how he would have done things differently alongside Van Gaal. Perhaps Giggs did not want to undermine Moyes or Van Gaal, coaches with a wealth of experience in England and Europe, or felt sheepish as the sole Brit surrounded by Dutch coaches. Giggs occasionally appeared passive aggressive alongside Van Gaal, perhaps agitating to critique United's football like his friend Paul Scholes often did. Or smash Van Gaal's clipboard to smithereens.
For various reasons, Giggs remained the silent assistant and interviews were only granted when he was promoting a business venture. Giggs might rightly wonder what he had to gain from addressing the media when that was the manager's obligation, but many supporters felt this adopted Mancunian would have been a creditable representative for them at a time United were suffering a graver identity crisis than Jason Bourne. Instead, Giggs' detractors formed an unflattering image of him.
Van Gaal barely changed during two robotic seasons but United lacked a headstrong assistant to challenge him. Giggs would have earned more support from United fans had he constructively questioned Van Gaal, while his managerial credentials would have also been bolstered, yet he often appeared withdrawn.
Giggs had witnessed how an assistant could wield influence without breaching his manager's trust. United fans told him to 'f**k off' the day after Roy Keane left, Keane found him so monotonous he asked him if he 'made love' to his wife at the same time, and RedIssue nicknamed him Queirozzzz, but without Carlos Queiroz Sir Alex Ferguson's reign might have ended with just one European Cup.
Archie Knox, Brian Kidd and Steve McClaren sampled success as Ferguson's No.2 yet Queiroz elevated United to a level of tactical sophistication that had previously been beyond them under their greatest manager. Tactics were always Ferguson's Kryptonite but Queiroz's input was so effective he could be forgiven for implementing ideas as tedious as his press conferences, such as the time he meticulously placed mats on the Carrington training pitch to mark where United players should be when Barcelona were in possession during their 2008 Champions League semi-final. United should have played more adventurously against Frank Rijkaard's bickering Barca, but the 1-0 aggregate triumph justified the approach.
Maybe Giggs was, like the players, shackled by Van Gaal, but there was no inclination for Mourinho to retain the Welshman after he was complicit in the failings of both Moyes' and Van Gaal's regimes. Giggs was, after all, the opposition scout under Van Gaal, a task he assigned Mourinho with at Barcelona. Judging by United's results, Giggs was about as convincing as Sir Bobby Charlton greeting Mourinho.
Of the two possible coaching departures from United, Warren Joyce's would have harmed the club significantly more than Giggs's. Joyce cut his teeth in the depths of Division Three with Hull before venturing out to Belgium and has spent eight years honing gems from the United academy who have, over the last year alone, contributed to Leicester's title triumph and Northern Ireland's first major tournament qualification in 30 years. Joyce has handled juniors and journeymen and would be a more valuable conduit between the players and Mourinho than Giggs.
Giggs had to leave. He turns 43 in November. Mourinho was 40 when he guided Porto to the Champions League in 2004 and Pep Guardiola was 38 in his maiden campaign. Giggs has, unintentionally, given the impression he is as entitled as Little Lord Fauntleroy when he needs to earn his stripes.
www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/sport/football/man-utd-news-giggs-mourinho-11419513#ICID=sharebar_twitter
.
"United’s flag is deepest red, it shrouded all our Munich dead. Before their limbs grew stiff and cold, their heart’s blood dyed it’s ev’ry fold. Then raise United’s banner high, beneath it’s shade we’ll live and die. So keep the faith and never fear." 
