Vidic Or Brown??

neville4president United Youth Teamer Posts: 99	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 10:58:14 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by neville4president on Jun 4, 2006 10:58:14 GMT Ok guys.... VDS G Neville Rio ----- Henize 3 of the best defenders in the world...but who fills the gap. Ive been SO impressed with Vidic and Brown this season, I just cant decide, HELP!! *John*
	"The Bayen Munich Players Are On Their Knees, They Dont Know Whats Hit Them - MANCHESTERS HIT THEM"

Dizzy United Starting XI Member of the Month - January 07 "He's so dense that light bends around him." Posts: 4,161	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 11:17:26 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by Dizzy on Jun 4, 2006 11:17:26 GMT I've not been able to decide all season either, but I think we should first start out with Rio and Brown, and then depending on how good either one of them is, if needed put Vidic in as a replacement.

Crilly
United Reserve Player

I'm not gonna hurt ya, Alfie!

Posts: 377

Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 11:30:40 GMT

Post by Crilly on Jun 4, 2006 11:30:40 GMT

Brown is immense, and at the moment wins the vote by a mile. His commitment to the cause has always been first class. His talent has never been questioned and his bone crunching tackles are admirable. When paired with Rio he has been the ultimate partner complementing Ferdinands game so well it has been reminiscent of the dolly and daisy days. I believe these two could even go on to become a more celebrated duo.

Wes's uncomprimising style allows Rio to play his more continental way of bringing the ball down and starting the attacking play from the back. Whats more is he is English so no language barriers either.

Im not dimissing Vidic though, I think in time he will prove to be a very good buy. He's only 24 and is built like a tank. His style is very similar to Brown's with his great no-nonsense tackling and how he throws himself in the way of shots etc. He gives a selection problem that has been missing for a while.

So at the moment I pick Brown, but Vidic is a good 2nd place.

One Love - Stretford End! MUFC The Religion.

All those who want Fergie out can go and support their local team, they are clearly scouse vermin.

Busby Boy Administrator Republik of Mancunia Staff plg%% Giggs, Scholes, Neville & Beckham%% Posts: 11,436	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 11:37:36 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by Busby Boy on Jun 4, 2006 11:37:36 GMT Rotation.

mancunian United Youth Teamer Posts: 67	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 11:41:37 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by mancunian on Jun 4, 2006 11:41:37 GMT A fully fit Brown is the best defender at United, he reads the game well, his passing is good, he is very strong, brave and has pace.

redrossi United Youth Teamer F**K LIVERPOOL Posts: 28	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 11:53:27 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by redrossi on Jun 4, 2006 11:53:27 GMT Vidic is still adapting so he's probably not at his best yet

redseven
United Reserve Player

you wanna mess with me?

Posts: 316

Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 12:03:26 GMT

Post by redseven on Jun 4, 2006 12:03:26 GMT

is there a way we could geneically mmake them both into one person?? lol

i prefer brown, when fully fit.....if not, has to be vidic.....iv been really impressed by him since he arrived

always play both of them plus rio.....lol....play the old wing back system.....

or maybe not

build a bonfire,build a bonfire,put the scousers on the top,put man city in the middle and burn the fucking lot!!!!!

Gabriel Heinze's tears cure cancer,it's a shame he doesn't cry!

neville4president United Youth Teamer Posts: 99	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 15:13:04 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by neville4president on Jun 4, 2006 15:13:04 GMT Rotation isnt an option in Centre Defence, although they would keep each other of their toes
	"The Bayen Munich Players Are On Their Knees, They Dont Know Whats Hit Them - MANCHESTERS HIT THEM"

stretfordend99
United Youth Teamer

Kiss the badge all you want Gaz! we'll love ya for it, Scousers'll hate ya for it....BONUS

Posts: 139

Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 15:29:17 GMT

Post by stretfordend99 on Jun 4, 2006 15:29:17 GMT

As impressed with Vidic i have been this season, it doesnt compare to supporting a manc who has been as loyal as anybody in the club (and the club inturn have stuck by him through his injuries).
There is no arguement for rotation as this has caused inconsistency in the past. So ... i dont know :-|... 5 at the back ? lol

Fergies new challenge? - To knock the rent boys off their fucking perch!

matkaman United Starting XI United. Posts: 2,106	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 18:56:14 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by matkaman on Jun 4, 2006 18:56:14 GMT Vidic and Brown,sell Rio .Silvestre would be a good enough back up.Dont like Rio ,120,000 a week not worth it ..One goal against liverpool over a few years does not earn him the right for a salary like that...

Red Yank Eric Cantona What? Was I supposed to kick it?? Posts: 13,496	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 4, 2006 19:40:43 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by Red Yank on Jun 4, 2006 19:40:43 GMT Brown gets my vote. I like Vidic but I think he still needs a bit of time to adapt before we consider starting him.

Alan
United Youth Teamer

Darren Fletcher's Number 1 Defender!

Posts: 45

Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 5, 2006 0:52:47 GMT

Post by Alan on Jun 5, 2006 0:52:47 GMT

matkaman said:

Vidic and Brown,sell Rio .Silvestre would be a good enough back up.Dont like Rio ,120,000 a week not worth it ..One goal against liverpool over a few years does not earn him the right for a salary like that...

Totally agree with you.

sahahaha United School Boy Posts: 0	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 5, 2006 0:58:00 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by sahahaha on Jun 5, 2006 0:58:00 GMT I'd rather see Brown and Vidic together, Rio's a fucking liability!

neville4president United Youth Teamer Posts: 99	Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 5, 2006 8:43:45 GMT Select Post Deselect Post Link to Post Member Give Gift Back to Top Post by neville4president on Jun 5, 2006 8:43:45 GMT I wonna get one of those T-shirts saying "Dont Blame Rio"
	"The Bayen Munich Players Are On Their Knees, They Dont Know Whats Hit Them - MANCHESTERS HIT THEM"

Scott
Administrator

Republik of Mancunia Staff

Posts: 7,406

Vidic Or Brown?? Jun 5, 2006 16:30:28 GMT

Post by Scott on Jun 5, 2006 16:30:28 GMT

Good question.

I like Vidic. He's got the kindof mentality and attitude I love in players. He's a proper nutcase at time, and a hard player. He'll make the crunching tackles. Rio and Wes have formed a great partnership this season, but Wes is very injury prone. I like him a lot, but once Vidic has more experience of the Premiership, I think him and Rio would be our best option.