Vidic Or Brown??

[missunited]

No contest for me, Brown ahead of Vidic any day. Brown has had a great season, he's a strong, reliable if not a tiny bit unlucky, defender. Vidic is new, giving him the space ahead of someone who's a proven first team player is not just unfair on Brown, but it will hardly encourage Vidic to play at his best every match if it's to come that easily to him.

Brown and Rio as first choice, they really compliment each other. Vidic as third choice.

[7even]

As much as I like Brown, I think he’s too injury prone. So I choose Vidic, as he looks the business. But, if Browns to stay fit, he’s certainly one of the best defenders around, no messing about type. A little healthy competition never hurt anyone, so Brown, Vidic, let the battle commence.

[Raving-Red]

I've bin nothing less than impressed with vidic certainly looks the part "tough as nails" but so is our wes and i'd still like to see the partnership with rio